Ghost Nets, Ulefone and Motherhood: contest clauses on irregular votes
In short Clause 9 of the terms of the Ghost Nets Exhibition Bali competition, held in July 2023, provided for disqualifying any entry that the Consulate-General determined to involve fraudulent practices such as fake Instagram accounts. The Ulefone and Motherhood clauses compared here use other words: Ulefone's allows invalidating affected votes or entries, and Motherhood's prohibits bots and scripts and allows disqualification of any person or business suspected of tampering with voting.
Published · Rules last checked · Jasa Vote Kontes
We bring votes through advertising channels that reach real people and do not break the organiser's terms. Before each launch, we set the channels beside the terms of the specific contest and compare them. Buy contest votes
Clause 9 of the Ghost Nets Exhibition Bali terms lets the Consulate-General disqualify entries
The Ghost Nets Exhibition Bali competition, an Instagram photo competition held from 21 July 2023 to 30 July 2023, was run by the Commonwealth of Australia through the Australian Consulate-General in Bali, according to its terms. The clause lists false email addresses and fake Instagram accounts among the fraudulent practices for which entries “will be disqualified from the Competition”.
The clause puts the determination in the hands of the Consulate-General, because it covers entries that the Consulate-General determines to have involved such practices. It also covers any other illegitimate behaviour to gain advantage over other entrants, and it states the consequence as disqualification from the Competition.
Other Ghost Nets Exhibition Bali terms cover judging, random winners and eligibility checks
Clause 8 of the terms says that Consulate-General staff judge the entries, and that three entries are chosen at random as winners. Clause 9, on fraudulent practices, follows under the same heading, Judging Criteria.
A separate clause, clause 5, says that the Consulate-General reserves the right to verify the eligibility of each entrant and to exclude or disqualify any entrant who does not meet the eligibility requirements.
The three clauses name different conduct and different consequences
The table puts each organiser's clause beside the kind of page it comes from, with the wording attached to its own organiser and its own contest.
| Organiser and contest | What the clause says | Consequence the clause names | Page type |
|---|---|---|---|
| Australian Consulate-General in Bali: Ghost Nets Exhibition Bali – Social Media Competition | Fraudulent practices, with false email addresses and fake Instagram accounts named as examples, and other illegitimate behaviour | Disqualification, where the Consulate-General so determines | Competition terms and conditions |
| Ulefone: contest rules | Suspected automated voting, duplicate voting, vote manipulation, fraud or other irregularities | Investigation, and invalidation of affected votes or entries | Contest rules |
| Motherhood: Motherhood Loves Community | Bots, macros, scripts and other automated voting systems, and vote manipulation in any form: strictly prohibited | Right reserved to disqualify any person or business suspected of tampering with voting, including any Nominee | Awards terms and conditions with a FAQ |
Ulefone and Motherhood word their clauses around votes, bots and tampering
Ulefone's contest rules say that the organiser may investigate suspected automated and duplicate voting, and they join to those two the words “vote manipulation, fraud, or other irregularities”. The same sentence lets the organiser invalidate affected votes or entries. The clause is worded with the verb may, which makes both the investigation and the invalidation powers of the organiser.
The terms of Motherhood Loves Community set out a prohibition: “The use of any automated voting system, bot, macro, script or vote manipulation in any form is strictly prohibited”. The same terms add that Motherhood “reserves the right to disqualify any person or business, including, without limitation, any Nominee” suspected of tampering with voting or abusing aspects of the Award.
A reader can check four things in the terms of each organiser
The quoted clauses differ in who acts, in what they cover and in what happens to an entry or a vote, and each difference is read in the clause itself.
- Find the clause that names the consequence: disqualification in the Ghost Nets Exhibition Bali terms, invalidated votes or entries in the Ulefone rules, and disqualification in the Motherhood terms.
- Check who acts: the Ghost Nets Exhibition Bali terms give the determination to the Consulate-General, and the Ulefone clause says the organiser may investigate.
- Check whether the clause reaches votes, entries or people, since Ulefone's names votes or entries and Motherhood's names any person or business, including any Nominee.
- Check what entering commits an entrant to, because the Ghost Nets Exhibition Bali terms state that by entering an entrant warrants being eligible.
Two guides on this site treat fan-voted awards and app voting as separate matters
The page on fan-voted awards deals with the counting of votes and the choice of winners in awards in Indonesia that fans vote on, and the companion page covers how viewers vote for contestants via mobile apps. Each of these pages stands in its own setting, apart from the clauses of the three organisers above.
Questions and answers
When did the Ghost Nets Exhibition Bali competition have its competition period, and when were winners announced?
The terms of the competition gave a period of 21 July 2023 to 30 July 2023. They placed the announcement of winners before 14 August 2023, and they said the Consulate-General would announce the winner by tagging them in a post on its Instagram page or website. The winner would also be notified by private message on Instagram within two business days of the announcement, the terms add.
Who could enter the Ghost Nets Exhibition Bali competition, and what did an entry involve?
According to the terms, entry was free and was open to Indonesia-based entrants. An entrant had to follow the Instagram account of the Consulate-General, post a photo of Ghost Nets moments on Instagram with the art exhibition as a background, and tag that account and use the hashtag the terms give. The terms call an entry valid when it is made in the form of an Instagram post with that information.
What does the Ulefone clause let the organiser do about suspected duplicate voting?
Ulefone's contest rules allow the organiser to investigate suspected duplicate voting. The clause names that conduct together with automated voting, manipulation, fraud and other irregularities, and for votes or entries affected by them it lets the organiser declare the vote or entry invalid. The power sits with the organiser, since the clause is written with the verb may.
What do the Motherhood Loves Community terms prohibit, and what may Motherhood do?
Automated voting systems, bots, macros, scripts and every form of vote manipulation are banned under the terms, which call the ban strict. Motherhood also reserves the right to disqualify any person or business, including any Nominee, suspected of tampering with voting or abusing aspects of the Award.
Does the Ghost Nets Exhibition Bali clause on fake accounts apply to the Ulefone and Motherhood contests?
No, the clause belongs to the terms of the Ghost Nets Exhibition Bali – Social Media Competition and covers entries in that competition. The Ulefone and Motherhood clauses are their own organisers' statements, each tied to its own contest, and each is read in its own scope.
Before relying on any summary of a contest's rules, read the organiser's own clause on fraud and voting, and note who decides and what the clause says happens to the entry or the vote.
Sources
- GHOST NETS EXHIBITION BALI – SOCIAL MEDIA COMPETITION · bali.indonesia.embassy.gov.au
- Bear Contest Rules – Ulefone Global · Ulefone
- Motherhood Loves Community Terms & Conditions - FAQ | Motherhood · Motherhood
- How Fan-Voted Awards in Indonesia Count Votes and Pick Winners · Jasa Vote Kontes
- How Viewers Vote for Contestants via Mobile Apps in Indonesia · Jasa Vote Kontes